For our project, we wanted to build a potato gun.Until that time, we had only heard of potato guns that were fueled by hairspray or a similar combustible substance.Mr. Murray advised us to build a pneumatic (air-powered) gun because the combustion-powered guns were less reliable and not conducive to experiments.
We downloaded several potato gun plans from the Internet and compared them to determine which model would be best for our experiment.Our criteria consisted of:
The basic pneumatic air cannon consists of a body
and barrel connected by a bell reducer, a female adapter connected to the
body, and a diaphragm held in place between the adapter and a cleanout
plug through which air is pumped using an air compressor, bicycle pump,
etc. Some models are equipped with a valve attached to the cleanout
plug that seals off the air prior to the launch. When compressed
air is pumped into the cannon, the pressure forces the corners of the diaphragm
around the edge of the barrel, sealing it off and directing the air
flow into the outer chamber of the body. When the nozzle of the air
source is removed, the diaphragm releases the seal over the barrel,
allowing air pressure from the outer chamber to flow into the barrel and
build up behind the potato, thus initiating the launch. If
the air cannon is equipped with a valve switch, the switch is flipped
before removing the air source, thus sealing the outer chamber,
and then released to break the seal of the diaphragm on the barrel.
Our first step in construction was to cut the PVC
pipes that made up the body of the air cannon. We cut a 36" length
of 3" PVC pipe for the outer chamber and a 72" length of PVC pipe 1.5"
in diameter for the inner chamber and barrel using a hand saw. We
then cut a 3 3/16" diaphragm from a plastic bin lid with an Exacto knife.
After drilling a hole in the cleanout plug, we glued the bell reducer
and the female adapter to each end of the 3" pipe. We placed the
diaphragm and the female adapter and screwed in the cleanout plug.
We then pushed the barrel through the reducer until it sat firmly against
the diaphragm and glued it in place.
We began our testing procedure by prepping our
ammunition. We selected ten potatoes of comparable size and weighed
each potato to determine the smallest mass. Using a piece of PVC
pipe, we cut each potato to ensure a snug fit inside the barrel of the
air cannon. We then re-weighed each potato and trimmed each to equal
the mass of the smallest potato, 0.6 kg.
Our next step was to prepare the launch site. We propped the air cannon on a sawhorse and calculated the angle of trajectory using trigonometry. We kept the angle of trajectory constant to isolate the pressure variable in determining the distance.
While setting up another trial, we accidentally
pushed the potato too far into the barrel, past the 2.5" mark.
Because it would be impossible to retrieve the potato, we decided
to move the potato 6.5 inches down the barrel and launch it using 400 kPa
of compressed air. The potato flew 39.6 m., over two times
the length it flew when only 2.5" down the barrel. Our examination
of this unexpected increase in distance led us to form an interesting theory.
Data Results
(Return to T of C)
The force propelling a potato through the barrel of an air cannon is the compressed air building up from behind the potato. The farther the potato is from the compressed air, the farther the air has to travel to reach the potato and push it through the tube. Because it has to travel some distance, the compressed air decreases in pressure due to the increased volume in which it can expand. Therefore, by the time the compressed air reaches the potato, the force it exerts on the potato is lessened. However, if the potato is pushed farther down into the tube, the compressed air has less room to both travel and expand; therefore, it retains more of its air pressure and can exert a greater force on the potato to propel it through the barrel. Also, when the potato reaches the end of the barrel, the air seal is broken and the compressed air is released into the atmosphere, no longer using force to give the potato momentum. If the potato was situated closer to the opening of the barrel, the compressed air would have little time to exert force on the potato before it was released into the atmosphere. However, if the potato was farther down into the barrel, the compressed air would have an increased amount of time to exert a force on the potato, thus accelerating it to the maximum velocity it could reach using the available pressure before the potato reached the end of the barrel and broke the air seal. because the potato was positioned farther down the tube, it would have more time to accelerate and more time for the potential energy in the compressed air to be converted to potato inertia, thus providing greater launch propulsion.
With this in mind, we increased the distance
of the potato to 12.5" down the barrel and continued our launch.
Our first trial with 300 kPa of compressed air yielded a 41.12 m. launch,
with 400 kPa a 58.5 m. launch, and with 500 kPa a 83.2 m. launch.
We repeated our 500 kPa launch, yielding 81.08 m., which demonstrated
the relative accuracy of our air cannon.
We were able to create formulas to project distance
based on pressure by analyzing the data we had gathered. At
first, we entered the data into a program to find a linear equation.
After re-entering the data to check the equation, we found that the
data didn't quite match up to the values produced by our equation.
At first, we assumed that the equation was an estimate, but
as we graphed the data points, we realized that the graphs were in
quadratic form and not linear. We re-entered the data in a quadratic
program and found two equations: for the 2.5" graph, y = (-1.38165
E -4)x ^ 2 + (.1188155)x - 8.5798 and for the 12.5" graph, y = (3.659
E -4)x ^ 2 + 32.94.
Our accidental discovery about potato position in the barrel of the air cannon provided an insight into the process a cannon undergoes in launching a potato. Our mistake really helped us to understand the principles of air pressure and pneumatic-powered mechanisms, more so than would explanations or diagrams. Other possible experiments could compare distances based on potato position while keeping pressure constant, which, if not just interesting, could aid in potato gun design reconfiguration for a greater launch distance.
1. Pneumatic Spud Shooter: www2.csn.net/~bsimon/pngun.htm
This website was the most informative and had the plans we ended up using
to build our gun. The directions are fairly simple and all of the
parts are easily procured.
2. Ultimate Potato Gun Page: angelcities.com/members/spudgun/spudgun.html
This page contains information on both pneumatic and combustion potato
guns, as well as ideas and tips on firing and designing cannons.
3. The Spudgun Technology Center: www.goldmann.com/spudgun.html
This website has incredibly high-tech potato gun plans- if you are really
into mechanical and engineering stuff, this one's for you.
4. The Potato Cannon Page: www.people.cornell.edu/pages/mas63/cannon/history.html
This site has a very simple design for a pneumatic gun, plus a history
of potato cannons and schematics.
5. Tony's Spudgun Page: www.tommasi.org/spud/index.html
This site, like the Spudgun Technology Center, features incredibly complicated
designs with high-tech parts. Not for the amateur builder!